Skip to content

Thinking · Newsletter

Where our concepts actually come from

Not brainstorms. Four inputs produce concepts that run, and public ad data shows ideas spreading between brands as skits, dares and characters.

TL;DR. Concepts that survive contact with an ad account come from four places: the comments, the support and review backlog, the existing library taken apart, and the category next door. The whiteboard is the least productive source. Public ad data adds one warning: ideas already travel between brands inside a category, mostly as skits, dares and characters, so what feels new to you may already be crowded. Every concept should carry a note on where it came from.

People imagine concepting as a room with a whiteboard. In practice, the ideas that survive contact with an account come from four places, and the whiteboard is the least productive of them. This piece belongs to our longer guide to hooks and creative briefs.

1. The comments

On the client's own ads and on their competitors'. It is the only place buyers describe the product in their own words, unprompted, including the objections nobody on the brand side wants to write down.

Comments give you language, not just topics. The hostile ones are the most useful: they tell you which promise the ad made that the viewer did not believe.

2. The support and review backlog

What people complain about is what they cared enough to expect. Reviews are a list of promises that were made and not kept, which is a list of promises worth making properly.

Almost nobody on the creative side reads it, which is why it produces concepts competitors do not have.

3. The existing library

What already worked, decomposed. Not "run it again" but "what was the mechanism". A hook that worked usually worked for a reason that transfers: a tension, a reveal, a person on screen, a specific promise. We wrote about this at length in the most useful creative research is your own ad library.

4. The category next door

Gaming borrows from commerce and commerce borrows from gaming, constantly, and the borrowed device is fresh precisely because the audience has not been trained on it yet. Our piece on which gaming conventions transfer to commerce covers which devices travel and which break on the way.

What public ad data shows about borrowed ideas

Flixr Studio, our own tool, reads public ads ad by ad. One of the things it does is group ads that play the same creative idea across brands: the same dare, the same skit template, a licensed character used the same way. These groupings are made by a model and checked against examples, and "who ran it first" means who launched it earlier in the Meta Ad Library, never proof that anyone copied anyone.

The set behind this section is 12,150 public Meta Ad Library ads from 23 game brands, launched between October 2024 and November 2026, nearly all since July 2026. Studio has watched them since October 2026. The concept list was computed on 5 November 2026.

What Studio found Count
Distinct concepts across the 23 brands 350
Concepts run by two or more brands 38
Brands that appear in at least one shared concept 17 of 23
Shared concepts that are skits or UGC templates 14
Shared concepts that are messaging devices (a dare, a come-back letter) 12
Shared concepts that are a character or licensed IP used the same way 9
Fake gameplay concepts run by more than one brand 1 of 48

What travels is the message, not the mechanic. Of 48 fake gameplay concepts, only one shows up at a second brand. What moves is skits, messaging devices and characters.

Borrowing inside a category is fast. For the 36 shared concepts with a clear second brand, the median gap between the first brand's launch and the second brand's was about 40 days, and 15 of them reached a second brand within 30 days. One caveat: 31 of those 36 first launched before Studio started watching, so the first date is the Ad Library's reported start, and an idea may be older than it looks.

Followers often run more of it. In 11 of the 36, the brands that launched later ran more ads on the idea than the brand that ran it first. A dare inviting the viewer to delete the app if they do not hit a jackpot appeared at six brands; the first ran 5 ads on it, the five that followed ran 196 between them. That says nothing about whether the dare works. It says that by the time an idea is visible in your category, it is no longer yours.

The other pattern is where ideas cross genre lines. They do, but rarely. A skit in which an undercover beggar is revealed as the true king started in a strategy game's ads in July 2026 and appeared in a social casino game's ads in October. A skit about returning a lost item for a reward moved from social casino to a solitaire card game. Most shared concepts stayed inside one genre: 28 of the 38 involve at least one social casino brand, a genre that makes up 8 of the 23 brands.

Where Flixr stands

We agree with the four inputs, in roughly the order above, and the data sharpens rather than changes them. Our reasoning:

The category is a check, not a source. Reading rivals is useful, but mostly to learn what is already crowded. When 38 ideas have spread across 17 brands, many within a month, an idea lifted from a direct rival arrives late and shared. We would rather know what the category already runs so a concept can avoid it, than mine it for concepts.

Next door is under-used, and the data is consistent with that. Cross-genre moves exist in the set but are the exception. That fits our view that the borrowed device is fresh because the audience has not seen it, though a public ad library cannot tell us whether those crossings worked. We hold it as a view, grounded in the reasoning, not as a measured result.

Steal the reason, not the scene. The cheap move is to copy the scene. The better move is input 3 applied to someone else's ad: name the mechanism (a status reversal, a dare, a reveal) and build a new scene around it.

How we work: creative and media sit in one team, and the weekly loop runs brief, make, launch, read, log. The log is where the input field lives, and Flixr Studio reading the category is how we check whether an idea is already everywhere before we make it.

The rule

A concept enters production with a note on which input produced it. If that field is blank, it came from the whiteboard, and in our view whiteboard ideas have a worse hit rate than any of the four above. If the input is "a rival ran it", the note should also say what we changed, because the scene is probably already in the viewer's feed.

Questions people ask

Where do good ad concepts come from? From buyers' own words (comments, reviews, support tickets), from your own past ads taken apart for the mechanism, and from devices borrowed from a neighbouring category. Brainstorms produce fewer concepts that last.

Should we copy what competitors are running? Use it to see what is crowded, not as a source. In Flixr Studio's public game ads, shared ideas often reached a second brand within weeks, and later brands frequently ran more of them than the first. Copy the reason an idea works, not its scene.

What kinds of ideas spread between brands? Messages more than mechanics. Among 38 concepts run by two or more game brands, skits, messaging devices and characters made up 35; only one of 48 fake gameplay concepts appeared at a second brand.

How do you track where a concept came from? Add a required source field to the brief: comments, reviews, own library, next-door category, or rival. Review hit rates by source every few months.

Sources: Flixr Studio queries over public Meta Ad Library ads (game_ads, game_concepts, game_concept_list), run 7 November 2026; Flixr Studio data guide (concept and caveat definitions); flixr.co About page.

Keep reading

All thinking

Let's open the logbook.

Name three rivals. We'll send back a read of your live ads against theirs: what you all say, who's on screen, and what's lasting.

Or email admin@flixrstudios.co.