Thinking · Newsletter
Why we work with actors rather than influencers
Why we cast paid actors and creators, not influencers, for performance testing: script control, repeatability, rights, and the disclosure rule.
TL;DR. For most performance work we cast paid actors and creators from a roster rather than booking influencers, for three practical reasons: control over the script, the ability to repeat a test, and clean usage rights. Influencers are the right buy when their audience is the asset. Public game ads point the same way: ordinary people on screen are far more common than creators. One rule comes with it: an actor must never be passed off as a real customer.
We keep a roster of paid actors and creators rather than booking influencers for most performance work. It is not an ideological position. It is a production one, and the reasons are practical. This piece is part of our guide to UGC ads for performance.
Control over the script
An influencer brings an audience and a voice, and the voice is the point, which means the script bends to them. For brand work that is the whole value. For performance work, where you are testing a specific message against a specific audience, it makes controlled comparison almost impossible.
Repeatability
Testing needs the same person delivering different messages, or different people delivering the same one. Influencer scheduling does not accommodate that. A roster does. When a hook works, you want five variants of it this week, not a reshoot in six weeks when the person is free.
Rights
Paid creators sign. Usage is clean, duration is clean, and nothing has to be renegotiated when an asset works and you want to run it for another six months. That last part is where influencer deals most often become expensive.
What public game ads show
Flixr Studio, our own tool, reads public ads one by one, including who is on screen. The set is 12,150 public Meta Ad Library ads from 23 game brands, launched between October 2024 and November 2026, nearly all since July 2026, which Studio has watched since October 2026. Of those, 12,122 videos and images have been read. Each person on screen is labelled by kind: a real person (an actor in a skit, a player, someone in the street), a creator (an influencer or streamer presenting or playing), or a celebrity.
| Who is on screen | Share of read ads | Brands using it |
|---|---|---|
| Real person (actor, player, passer-by) | 19.7% | 23 of 23 |
| Celebrity | 10.8% | 6 |
| Creator or streamer | 7.6% | 16 |
The same pattern holds in a recent cohort. Of the 4,538 read ads launched between 2 and 20 October 2026, 19.9% show a real person (18 brands), 6.3% a creator (13 brands) and 16.7% a celebrity (5 brands).
The UGC concepts tell the same story. Scripted skits with actors are the most common people-led concept, at 13.7% of read ads across 19 brands. Streamer reactions are 3.8% (9 brands) and reviews to camera 2.7% (17 brands). Celebrity or pro endorsements are 8.7%, but from only 6 brands.
Two cautions. These are a model's readings: on social casino ads, Studio's evaluation found characters in about 70% of cases. And a public ad library shows what brands chose to run, not what worked; competitors' spend is not visible. The shares tell you what game advertisers build, not what wins.
What the platforms say
The platforms ask for people, not specifically for famous people. TikTok's creative best practices say: "We recommend featuring people such as creators, employees, or customers to capture attention and increase engagement."
Where Flixr stands
We agree with our own default, and the public data is consistent with it. Game advertisers put ordinary people on screen in about a fifth of their ads, across every brand in the set, while creators appear in fewer than one in ten and celebrities are concentrated in a handful of brands. That is what you would expect if most teams treat people on screen as a testing tool and a famous face as a deliberate, occasional purchase.
We would also not claim that actors outperform influencers. We have no public evidence for that, and the data above shows choices, not results. Our position rests on the reasoning: a performance test needs a controlled variable, a repeatable cast and rights that do not expire when the ad starts working.
How we work: the weekly loop runs brief, make, launch, read, log, with 7,600+ creators ready to brief, so a hook that works can be recast and reshot the same week. For examples of scripted UGC built as a series around one question each, see the Prose pieces in our showcase, such as Why Are My Ends Splitting So Fast? and Why Does My Hair Dry So Fast? (UGC, authentic style). Our services pages for UGC ads for games and for commercial brands cover the production side, and we are AI-native and we still pay actors covers where generated people fit.
Where influencers are still right
When the audience is the asset. A launch, a credibility problem, a category where a specific person's endorsement genuinely changes the purchase decision. Those are real, and they are not performance creative in the testing sense.
The honest summary
Actors are the right default for volume testing. Influencers are the right choice when you are buying someone's audience rather than their performance. Most teams use one where they needed the other.
Questions people ask
Are actors or influencers better for performance ads? For testing, actors and paid creators, because you control the script, can repeat the cast and own the usage. Influencers are better when you are buying their audience or their credibility.
How common are creators in mobile game ads? In Flixr Studio's read of 12,122 public game ads, creators or streamers appear in 7.6%, ordinary people such as actors in 19.7%, and celebrities in 10.8%, the last from only 6 of 23 brands.
What does TikTok recommend? Its creative best practices recommend "featuring people such as creators, employees, or customers to capture attention and increase engagement." People, not necessarily influencers.
Sources: Flixr Studio queries over public Meta Ad Library ads (game_ads, game_ad_characters), run 7 November 2026, and the Studio data guide; TikTok Ads Manager help, Creative best practices (ads.tiktok.com/help/article/creative-best-practices); flixr.co About page.